Our Favorite Places to Eat in Montauk
When it comes to dining, Montauk offers a delicious array of options that cater to every palate. From fresh seafood straight from the ocean to cozy breakfast nooks and upscale dining spots, Montauk’s culinary landscape is as diverse as it is delightful. Whether you’re a foodie looking for your next great meal or just in need of a quick bite, here are some of our favorite places to eat in this coastal paradise.
Goldberg’s Bagels & Deli
While primarily known for their bagels, Goldberg’s Bagels & Deli also serves up a mean cup of coffee. Stop by for a freshly brewed coffee and one of their famous bagels with cream cheese or a hearty breakfast sandwich. The no-frills, friendly atmosphere makes it a great spot for a quick and satisfying breakfast.
The Lobster Roll (LUNCH)
Kick off your culinary adventure at The Lobster Roll, affectionately known as LUNCH. This iconic spot has been serving up delicious seafood since 1965. Their lobster roll, packed with succulent chunks of lobster and served on a perfectly toasted bun, is a must-try. Pair it with a side of their famous coleslaw and enjoy the classic Montauk experience.
Joni’s Kitchen
For a healthy and hearty breakfast or lunch, head over to Joni’s Kitchen. This cozy spot is known for its fresh, organic ingredients and creative menu. Try their acai bowls, loaded with fresh fruits and granola, or the popular breakfast burrito for a satisfying start to your day.
Harvest on Fort Pond
If you’re in the mood for a more upscale dining experience, Harvest on Fort Pond is the place to be. This Italian-inspired eatery offers a beautiful setting with views of the pond and a menu featuring locally sourced ingredients. Share a wood-fired pizza or indulge in their famous mussels, and don’t forget to explore their extensive wine list.
The Crow’s Nest
For a romantic dinner with a view, The Crow’s Nest is an excellent choice. Nestled on Lake Montauk, this rustic-chic restaurant offers a menu that highlights seasonal and local produce. Enjoy dishes like grilled octopus, local fish, and house-made pastas while taking in the serene lake views.
John’s Drive-In
For a casual, family-friendly meal, John’s Drive-In is a Montauk staple. Known for its juicy burgers, crispy fries, and delicious homemade ice cream, this retro eatery is perfect for a laid-back lunch or dinner. The relaxed atmosphere and classic diner fare will transport you back in time.
Inlet Seafood Restaurant
Seafood lovers should not miss Inlet Seafood Restaurant. Owned and operated by six local fishermen, this spot guarantees the freshest seafood in town. From sushi to lobster, the menu offers a wide range of ocean delights. Enjoy your meal with panoramic views of the inlet and the Atlantic Ocean.
668 The Gig Shack
For a taste of Montauk’s vibrant nightlife, head to 668 The Gig Shack. This lively spot offers a diverse menu with a global twist. Try the Montauk calamari, the famous fish tacos, or the grass-fed burger. With live music and a buzzing atmosphere, it’s a great place to unwind after a day at the beach.
Montauk’s dining scene is a testament to its vibrant culture and commitment to quality. From relaxed eateries to elegant restaurants, there’s a culinary adventure waiting for you around every corner. So, whether you’re savoring fresh seafood with an ocean view or enjoying a hearty breakfast to start your day, Montauk offers a dining experience that’s sure to be unforgettable. Come hungry and leave happy, indulging in the diverse and delicious flavors that this charming town has to offer. Bon appétit!
