Our Favorite Coffee Shops in Montauk
Montauk is more than just a summer getaway; it’s also a haven for coffee lovers. Whether you’re in need of a morning pick-me-up, an afternoon break, or a cozy spot to catch up with friends, Montauk’s coffee scene has something to offer. Here are some of our favorite coffee shops in this charming coastal town.
Left Hand Coffee
Start your coffee adventure at Left Hand Coffee, a local favorite known for its commitment to sustainability and high-quality brews. Located right in the heart of Montauk, this cozy coffee shop offers a variety of organic, fair-trade coffee options. Don’t miss their signature nitro cold brew or a classic flat white. The laid-back atmosphere and friendly staff make it a perfect spot to relax and enjoy your coffee.
Bluestone Lane Beach Collective
If you’re looking for a place that offers more than just great coffee, Bluestone Lane Beach Collective is the spot for you. This Australian-inspired café not only serves excellent coffee but also offers a delicious menu of healthy bites and brunch options. Enjoy your flat white with a side of avocado smash toast or a fresh acai bowl. The bright, airy space and ocean views make it a perfect spot for a leisurely breakfast or brunch.
Naturally Good Foods and Café
Naturally Good Foods and Café is a hidden gem in Montauk, offering organic and health-focused options. Their coffee menu includes everything from classic drip coffee to espresso-based drinks, all made with organic beans. Pair your coffee with one of their freshly baked muffins or a hearty breakfast burrito. The café’s commitment to natural and wholesome ingredients shines through in every cup.
Bake Shoppe
If you’re searching for a spot that has baked goods, check out the only true bakery on Eastern Long Island—Bake Shoppe. With products made from scratch daily, including renowned whole grain breads and famous Jelly Croissant. The ever-evolving selection also features sugar-free and gluten-free options. For breakfast on the go, enjoy made-to-order egg sandwiches on our freshly baked rolls and croissants, or try our Montauk Beach Breakfast Wraps.
MTK Café
For a friendly and relaxed coffee experience, MTK Café is the place to be. This family-run café serves up delicious coffee along with a variety of breakfast and lunch options. Their iced coffee is a must-try, especially on a warm summer day. The welcoming atmosphere and homey feel make it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
Duryea’s Market & Café
Stop by Duryea’s for your morning coffee, to-go food, or even shop a mix of culinary products. Known for their breakfast, pastries, and beverages, Duryea’s is a local favorite sure to serve up your morning brew needs.
Ditch Witch Coffee
For those mornings when you’re heading straight to the beach, Ditch Witch Coffee is a convenient and beloved spot. This food truck, parked near Ditch Plains Beach, serves up strong, delicious coffee that’s perfect for grabbing on the go. Pair your coffee with one of their famous breakfast burritos or a freshly baked pastry. It’s the ideal spot to fuel up before a day of surfing or sunbathing.
Montauk’s coffee scene is as diverse and inviting as the town itself. From trendy spots with a surf vibe to cozy cafés with organic offerings, there’s a coffee shop for every taste. So whether you’re a local or just visiting, take some time to explore these fantastic coffee shops and savor the flavors of Montauk, one cup at a time. Happy sipping!
